Origins of the Papacy – Peter do you Love Me?

This post is also available in: Italian

The origins of the Papacy can be found in the dialogue between Jesus and Simon Peter in John 21, a gospel traditionally read during Eastertide.   The question,”Peter, do you love me?” is followed by the command  “Feed my sheep.”  The pope, shepherd and successor of Peter, has a role that has not to do with privilege but with sacrifice.  For the 3rd Sunday of Easter, cycle C. 

On many occasions I’ve heard people object to the papacy.  Often, they say something like this: “I just can’t believe that one man on earth, the Pope, is holier than everyone else.”

So who ever said that being sinless is either a prerequisite or a consequence of being named Pope?

Pope & Papacy

The Pope, the bishop of Rome, is the successor of Peter, who spent the last years of his life leading the Christians of the eternal city.  And here is an interesting fact.  None of the four canonical gospels (not to mention Acts and Galatians) try to hide the fact that Peter sinned often and sinned big.

By the way, if the “patriarchal, controlling” leaders of the early Catholic Church altered the story about Jesus as some suggest, don’t you think they would have “fixed” these embarrassing stories?

Yet while all agree Peter was weak and imperfect, they all also agree that he was given a unique responsibility.  Only Peter got a name-change from Jesus himself (from Simon to “Peter” meaning rock).  Only Peter was told by Christ on Holy Thursday night “I have prayed for you that your faith never fail and when you’ve repented, go and strengthen your brethren” (Luke 22: 31-32).  And when Jesus, after the resurrection, cooked a fish breakfast for the apostles (John 21), it was only to Peter that Jesus put the question “do you love me?”

peter papacy pope john 21 facebook

The Dialogue of Peter with the Risen Christ

But why did Jesus ask him the same question three times?  Perhaps Peter needed to atone for his three-fold denial of Christ by a three-fold profession of love.  Perhaps, given Peter’s track record of getting it wrong, the Lord really wanted to be sure he got his point across.  Here’s the point–

“Peter, your way of expressing penance for your sin and love for me will be to feed my sheep.  Remember, they are not your sheep, but mine.  Take care of them for me.  Do for them what I did for them.  Don’t just feed them.  Protect them.  Lay down your life for them if necessary.”

Website Option 2 undated maroon

From Fisherman to Universal Shepherd

Peter’s role as a shepherd is, in a way, unique because it is universal.  Despite his human frailty, he is given care of all the Churches.  And, if we take Luke 22:31-32 seriously, he is called to be the shepherd of all the shepherds.  That’s a big responsibility.  In fact, it is a crushing burden which he and his successors could never fulfill by human power alone.

That’s why we pray for the Pope (meaning “Papa” or father) in every Catholic Eucharist across the globe – He needs the grace of the Holy Spirit to fulfill his role.  The bit about Peter stretching out his hands so that others could lead him where he does not want to go – this does not just refer to his crucifixion under Nero, but to the daily laying his life down for his flock, the “white martyrdom” that we saw so clearly in the weary but relentless witness of St. John Paul II in his final years.

Shepherd of Many Shepherds

In another way, though, Peter’s role of a shepherd is not unique.  It is exemplary for all of us sheep who are called to become ourselves shepherds and leaders, despite our own frailty and sinfulness.  Some are called to be bishops, successors of the apostles, entrusted with pastoral care of a portion of Christ’s flock.  Some are called to be priests and deacons, who assist a bishop in his apostolic mission.  Some are called to be catechists, youth ministers and teachers, who also play a role in the feeding of the sheep.

And most of us are called to be parents, shepherds of what the Second Vatican Council calls “the domestic church.”  Parents, say St. Thomas Aquinas and St. John Paul II, have a pastoral role much like that of a parish priest.  In fact John Paul II, in his letter Familiaris Consortio, says that Christian parents exercise “a true ministry of the Church.”

John 21 – Call to Feed the Sheep

On whatever level, the call to feed and care for the sheep is a call to sacrifice, not privilege.  It has its moments of exaltation and profound satisfaction, and it has its moments of agony as well.  Yet if we’ve learned anything from the passion, it’s that suffering is the true and necessary test of love, as well as love’s most authentic and powerful expression.

So let us not be afraid to be shepherds.  The Good Shepherd will empower us with His Spirit.  And let’s pray with gratitude and compassion for those who shepherd us.

This post on Peter as shepherd and the Papacy is offered as a reflection on the readings for the 3rd Sunday of Easter, cycle C  (Acts 5:27b-41; Psalm 30; Revelation 5:11-14; John 21 1-19).

For more resources for the Easter Season, see the EASTER section of the Crossroads Initiative Library.

For more on Palm Sunday and Holy Week, see the Resurrection section of the Crossroads Initiative Library.

Banner/featured image Christ’s Charge to St. Peter (cartoon for the Sistine Chapel) by Raphael (1515). Public Domain.

1 Comment
  • Jane Jones
    Posted at 08:17h, 27 April

    I am very thankful for the pope, no matter who he is, and love listening to him and striving to obey him with the blind and loving obedience of Mary our Mother. Viva Papa Francesco!

Post A Comment